There is a poster that is quite active on SE right now who persistently post questions with no source code. It's not that they are very poor quality posts, he just needs to make a bit more effort.

I just commented and voted down his post. Is that the right approach?

Can we use a custom Visualforce component twice on the same Visualforce page?

1 Answer 1


I think the way you handled it was perfect. We don't want to discourage users from posting, but we also want to make sure we keep the site full of good, useful information. Downvoting a user who consistently doesn't provide a good question is a good way to show them what they are doing is incorrect but it doesn't remove their question from everyone's view.

I searched for a bit and couldn't really find anything related to this, but I had an idea that maybe we should provide new users some sort of consolidated feedback on what we as a community expect their questions to be like. Using that as inspiration, I started this thread - Tips and Tricks for Asking a Good Question? - to discuss tips and tricks we can give users. Hopefully in future situations like this we can link to a thread like that and have the user get a wealth of information to provide us a perfect question which in turn will enable us to provide a perfect answer.

  • I agree completely - Voting is one of the features that makes the SFSE format better than other traditional message board formats in my opinion. Commented Feb 6, 2013 at 20:32

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .